Raising a Sensitive Child

Nourishing Body, Mind and Spirit

My current thoughts on vaccinations

8 Comments

As you can tell, I’ve been thinking a lot about vaccinations lately.

I thought that the whole issue had been put to rest after my son’s negative reaction to the MMR vaccination, but given his recent diagnosis with Job’s syndrome (a genetic immune disorder), his immunologist advised us that it would be in our son’s best interest to get him fully immunized.

Ack! My intuition told me right away that this would not be in his best interest. I knew that children whose immune systems are compromised are the ones that are most prone for being negatively affected by vaccinations. And, yes, I do very strongly believe that vaccinations can lead to autism, especially when a child is already immunocompromised. I also know that there are some individuals with Job’s syndrome who are also on the autism spectrum.

A couple of individuals with children that are diagnosed with Job’s syndrome mentioned that their doctors said that their children should not be vaccinated because their immune systems could not handle it. Plus a scientific study has shown that individuals with Job’s syndrome have poor immune responses to vaccinations.

My Heilkunst practitioner encouraged me to get grounded in the research so that I could base our decision not just on my intuition, but also on knowledge. And so I did. I was surprised at how much research I was able to find. I found so much research on the topic of the effects of vaccinations on allergies, anaphylaxis, neurological damage and autism that it broke my heart. It really broke my heart.

The scientific studies are out there, as well as countless stories of vaccine-injured children. How do we not know about them? How is it that I didn’t know about them? (You probably don’t know this, but I’m actually a scientist with a M.Sc. and have  co-authored and published 7 of my own papers in peer-reviewed scientific journals. I currently work as an environmental consultant and wildlife biologist as my day job.) It broke my heart as I felt that I had failed my son in that I didn’t dig deeper into the research earlier. Knowing what I know now, I would have chosen different.

Right from the start, I felt strongly against vaccinating, but my husband felt strongly for vaccinating, so we compromised by saying yes to some. In particular, we said yes to the vaccinations that have been around when we were kids. We figured that if we turned out alright, then those vaccinations must be safe enough.

Part of the problem is the number of shots that our children receive today (28 vaccinations in Canada and 36 in the US by the age of 5). I was born in the 1970s, and during that time, children received 10 vaccines before attending school. Even though my son has only received a total of 4 shots, he’s actually received the equivalent of 18 vaccinations (3 shots each of diptheria, tetanus, accellular pertussis, polio, Hib when he was 2, 4 and 6 months old and the MMR when he was 3.5 years old). So even though we only partially vaccinated him, he still received almost double the amount of vaccines than when my husband and I were children.

If I only knew what I know now…  Assuming that we still wanted him to be vaccinated for DTAP-IPV-HiB, if we had waited until he was 2 years old, he would have only needed one shot (equivalent of 5 vaccinations), not the 3 shots when he was 2, 4 and 6 months (equivalent of 15). The reason that they need so many shots when they are so young is that babies have poor immune responses to vaccinations when they are so young (which is another reason to delay them). Given that my son has struggled with asthma, it broke my heart to learn that by delaying the DTP vaccination, the risk of developing asthma is decreased.

If I could choose all over, I would not have vaccinated my son at all. I would have made a more informed decision. Or at least, I would have listened to my intuition, which wisely told me not to.

But, of course, I can’t go back in time. And I know why I didn’t delve into the scientific literature any earlier. He was 2 months old when he was scheduled to receive his first set of shots, and I was exhausted from raising an (already) sick and colicky child, who didn’t sleep (which means that I didn’t sleep). There was no time to do any research. Of course, I forgive myself (I need to). I did the best that I could at the time. We all do the best that we can as parents.

So why does my heart continue to break? Because the research is out there that we are damaging our children through vaccinations. The rates of allergies, asthma, anaphylaxis and autism are astronomical. Most of the children that I know need a puffer to control their asthma. Most of the children that I know have allergies. One in a 110 children have been diagnosed with an autism syndrome disorder. And yet we still continue to vaccinate our children.

It’s not the fault of the parents. The parents are simply doing what they think is best for their children. The pressure to vaccinate is tremendous (and is mandated by law in some places). Thankfully, in Canada, we have the right to choose. Nonetheless, the pressure to vaccinate is enormous. During my son’s doctors appointments (and there are many), we are constantly harrassed because our son isn’t fully vaccinated.

Well, we are now armed with knowledge. We have scientific research backing our decision of why we are not going to fully vaccinate our son. Yes, we are aware that his immune system is compromised. That is exactly why we are not going to be vaccinating him.

DH is mostly in agreement with me. We’ve definitely agreed that our son will not receive the following vaccinations:

  • flu vaccination (we are staying away from thimerosal [mercury], for obvious reasons);
  • chicken pox vaccination (it is a live vaccination and live vaccinations are contraindicated for children with severe immune disorders);
  • pneumonia vaccination; and
  • tetanus. He has already been vaccinated for tetanus, but his titer levels show that it didn’t take. Why would we want him to be vaccinated for this again, especially when it didn’t take the first three times, and given that it’s known that individuals with Job’s syndrome have a poor immune response to vaccines. Also, the tetanus vaccination is generally not available by itself, but is almost always lumped with diptheria. No thanks. (You can read some information about whether the tetatus vaccination is really necessary here).

The only one that we haven’t yet come to agreement with is meningitis. I’ve asked DH to read this paper about the danger of excessive vaccination during brain development, and if he’s not convinced by that point, I’ll start sharing the other research that I have found.*

All that being said, I believe that each family needs to come to their own decisions about vaccinations. Each family is different, each child is different. But, I believe that parents should be given the opportunity to make informed choices  and currently the medical establishment isn’t giving parents the opportunity to make informed choices.

I would encourage you to read some of the scientific research that is out there, and then make an informed choice. If you do choose to vaccinate, I’ve written a post on ideas of what you can do to minimize the negative effects of vaccinations.

*Update – December 2, 2010:  DH and I now agree that our son will not be vaccinated any further at this time.

Advertisements

8 thoughts on “My current thoughts on vaccinations

  1. Big hugs and also a thank you for posting on this topic.

    I also urge you to get a copy of Dr. Sherri Tenpenny’s book “Saying No to Vaccines – a resource guide for all ages” It has over 350+ medical references on the topic of vaccines and really helped us answer any questions we were faced with regarding no longer vaccinating anyone in our family after our daughter’s reaction.

    http://moralescrew.blogspot.com/2010/08/vaccine-reaction_20.html

    Also, I have many resources listed here in case you have questions you still need to answer for your family. And, there is a link to Guggie Daly’s post on Tetanus in the comments of this post as well that you may want to check out too.

  2. I am so sorry about your son. You are just an incredible mother and do so much for him, I am just amazed every time I read your blog. Thank you for all of your information, I am in the midst of thinking about vaccines and am reading a lot. We didn’t know any better when my son was born and he had all the shots until 6 months when I said, wait a minute, what is all this stuff. Then I have done some research and just have no idea what to do at this point. It’s nice to hear about everything you have learned. It makes me think… Which is good.
    Peace and Love to you and your family

  3. Tamara: Thank you for the hugs and for all of the incredible information. I will definitely get a copy of that book and also will take a look at all of the great information that you have posted on your blog. Thank you so much!

    Cassie: Thanks so much for your support and encouragement. It helps. Big hugs to you and your family.

  4. hey.
    experts always say the same thing. they advise to immunise when a child has a compromised immune system. i see the logic of course. but it’s a knee jerk reaction founded on very strict teaching and understanding.

    i’ve written a little on vaxing if you’re interested:
    http://holisticmum.blogspot.com/search/label/vaccination

    there’s a useful book i recommend there too.

    all the best.

  5. Hi Mon: Thanks for the comment. I have been reading what you’ve written about vaxing. I found it useful and balanced (thanks!). Thanks also for the book recommendation too (Raising a Vaccine Free Child).

  6. Hey…I’ve been so busy reading your other posts, I’m finally getting to this one. I’m still a little upset my son got a Hep B vaccine in the hospital, when he was in the NICU. I hadn’t done any reading on vaccines yet because I was planning to wait till he was two, anyway. But then they sprung that on me at the hospital and made it sound like he was at high risk if he didn’t get the shot. Then I started reading about vaccines and learned what Hep B was….ever since then I felt I can’t trust anything that vaccine proponents say. I hope that that vaccine didn’t damage his little newborn brain, but I can’t undo it. I’m so glad I waited till he was over two to do any more, and we’ve only done the Dtap. I’m not even sure I want to do any more than just the one shot…I have so much reading to do. I’m not doing anymore until I feel confident it’s a safe choice that has actual benefits.

    I’m slowly working through those vaccine articles. It’s really not fun reading all that stuff, but I feel like it really helps me make the best decision I can.

  7. Hi Lisa: It doesn’t make any sense at all to me that children in the states are given the Hep B vaccine when they are first born. Your son is lucky that to have you as his mom and that you waited until he was 2 years old until you started to consider vaccinations. I agree that reading all of those articles does help one to make a more informed decision. (I wish I had done it sooner, but what can you do? We just do the best that we can.)
    I didn’t read them all, but read enough of them to back up our decision not to do any more. We were also better able to defend our decision not to fully vaccinate our son when we talked to his pediatrican last week.

    Good luck and take care,
    Janice

  8. Pingback: Our current game plan « Raising a Sensitive Child

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s